Toolkit / Assessment

Assessment

Assess what each method is meant to teach

If you change the method but keep a recall-only exam, students will go back to memorising. Match the assessment to what the method practises.

What to assess, method by method

Case-based

ASSESS

The reasoning behind the decision, not just the answer

TOOLS

Decision memo, debrief contribution, reasoning rubric

Problem-based

ASSESS

Both the process and the product

TOOLS

Tutor observation, learning-issue log, short individual quiz

Flipped and active

ASSESS

Preparation first, then application in class

TOOLS

Low-stakes pre-class quiz, in-class task, muddiest-point data

Team and peer

ASSESS

Individual and team readiness, and team decisions

TOOLS

Individual quiz, team quiz, peer evaluation

Simulation

ASSESS

The quality of the prediction and the interpretation

TOOLS

Prediction sheet, results report, skills checklist

Project-based

ASSESS

Process, product and individual understanding

TOOLS

Milestone reviews, rubric, individual viva, contribution log

Reusable rubric

One four-level rubric covers most of these methods

Use it for case write-ups, problem reports, team applications and projects. Change the descriptors to your subject.

CriterionBeginningDevelopingProficientAdvanced
ReasoningStates an answer with no reasonsGives reasons with gaps or errorsClear, logical reasoning throughoutWeighs alternatives and trade-offs
Concepts and evidenceConcepts missing or misusedSome concepts used correctlyAccurate use of concepts and dataLinks concepts from several topics
CommunicationHard to followUnderstandable but unevenClear and well organisedClear, concise and persuasive
ReflectionNo reflectionDescribes what happenedExplains what worked and what did notTurns lessons into a changed plan

Share the rubric before the task starts, and weight the criteria to match the outcome.

Fair teamwork

Peer evaluation and individual checks

Peer evaluation form: for each memberRarelySomeMostlyAlways
Came prepared
Contributed ideas
Listened and built on others’ ideas
Completed agreed tasks on time
Helped resolve disagreements

Keeping individuals accountable

Roles that rotate

Chair, scribe and reporter change each session.

Individual before team

An individual quiz comes before the team quiz.

A short individual write-up

A one-minute reflection or a brief viva for each student.

A contribution log

Each member records what they did and when.

Start with peer evaluation as formative feedback, then give it a low weight.

Knowing it worked

Five quick ways to see whether a new method worked

Muddiest point

At the end of class, students write the one thing that is still unclear.

One-minute paper

Two prompts: the main idea today, and one question I still have.

Start, stop, continue

Students name one thing to start, one to stop and one to continue.

Three-question form

What helped? What got in the way? What one change would you make?

Pre and post quiz

Five questions on the same concept, before and after the session.

Keep a small portfolio: the lesson planner, your materials, two or three anonymised samples of student work and a one-page reflection.