Toolkit / Chapter 4

Chapter 4 of 6

Team-Based Learning and Peer Instruction

Two structured ways to make collaboration work, even in a class of a hundred.

Best forLarge classes where group work usually turns into chaos or free riding
Group sizeTBL: permanent teams of 5 to 7 in classes of 40 to 200. Peer instruction: any size
PreparationHigh for the first TBL module, then moderate. Peer instruction is low once you have questions
Session lengthTBL module: 1 to 2 sessions. Peer instruction: 5 to 15 minutes in any lecture

1 What it is

Both methods follow one logic: students prepare, test their understanding, argue it out with peers and apply it. Team-based learning (TBL) is a whole-module structure. Peer instruction (PI) is a short routine you can drop into any lecture. Many faculty start with PI and grow into TBL.

In TBL, permanent teams of five to seven complete each module: individual readiness test, the same test as a team, appeals and a short mini-lecture, then application exercises that follow the 4S rule (significant problem, same problem for all, specific choice, simultaneous reporting). In PI, you pose a conceptual question, students vote, discuss with a neighbour, and vote again.

Defining features

  • Preparation before class with accountability
  • Individual test, then team test with immediate feedback
  • Application problems with one specific choice, revealed together
  • Peer instruction: vote, discuss, re-vote, explain

What it is not

  • Ad hoc group work with a different group each week
  • Easy quiz questions that every student answers correctly
  • Peer evaluation used as a punishment instead of feedback

How a session runs

  1. PreparationStudents study assigned material before class
  2. Individual readiness testA short quiz taken alone on the pre-work
  3. Team readiness testThe same quiz retaken by the team with one answer sheet
  4. Appeals and mini-lectureTeams challenge questions in writing. Clarify only the weak concepts
  5. Application exerciseA hard problem with a specific choice, reported at the same moment
  6. Peer evaluationStructured feedback among team members

2 Background

Origins

Larry Michaelsen developed TBL in business education in the 1970s and 1980s to keep large classes interactive. Eric Mazur introduced peer instruction at Harvard in the early 1990s after finding his physics students could solve numerical problems but failed basic conceptual questions.

Learning theory

Social constructivism: explaining your thinking to a peer builds understanding. Cooperative learning research shows groups work when there is positive interdependence and individual accountability. The individual and team test combination builds both.

What the evidence says

Crouch and Mazur (2001) report ten years of data showing better conceptual understanding in peer instruction courses. Johnson, Johnson and Smith (1998) review the evidence for cooperative learning in college. For TBL, reviews in health professions report positive effects on engagement and performance, and acceptance rises as the routine becomes familiar.

The Indian context

One teacher with 60 or more students is the normal situation these methods were designed for. Scratch cards are not essential: coloured A to D cards or a free poll tool will do. Form teams yourself, mixing prior knowledge and language comfort, and introduce peer evaluation as formative feedback first.

3 Implementation across courses

Pick a subject to see a worked example. Adapt the topic to your own syllabus unit.

Antimicrobial classes (TBL)

Pre-reading on mechanisms and spectra. An individual quiz of 10 questions, then the team quiz. Application: choose the best antibiotic for four patient scenarios, all teams revealing at the same moment.

Students produce: Team decisions with written rationale

Excipient selection (PI)

ConcepTest: which change would increase disintegration time? Students vote, discuss and re-vote. Then a team exercise choosing excipients for a given drug profile.

Students produce: Re-vote data and a team excipient list

Chromatography troubleshooting

ConcepTests on peak tailing and shifting retention. Teams then receive four chromatograms and choose the most likely cause of each fault.

Students produce: Fault diagnosis with justification

Adverse reaction causality

Pre-read on WHO-UMC or Naranjo. Teams assess four adverse reaction reports and report their category simultaneously, then compare reasoning.

Students produce: Four causality assessments with evidence

Common pitfalls and how to avoid them

Teams change from week to weekKeep teams permanent for the whole course. Trust and shared experience are part of why TBL works
The readiness quiz is too easy or too hardAim for an individual average of about 60 to 70%. Make the application harder than the quiz
Application problems allow vague answersForce a specific choice from a small set, then ask teams to explain it
Peer instruction questions are trivialBuild wrong options from real misconceptions. Aim for 30 to 70% correct on the first vote
Grades cause anxietyGive early modules low weight and keep peer evaluation formative at first

4 Enriching your practice

This part is for you to work through on your own. Your ticks are saved in this browser only.

Reflection prompts

  • Where in my course do students understand the procedure but not the concept?
  • What are the three most common misconceptions I see in answer scripts?
  • How will I form teams so that no team is clearly stronger?
  • What would I do if the first vote on a question is 95% correct?

Readiness checklist

Try it this week

Write one ConcepTest from a misconception you have seen in an answer script. Use it in your next lecture, record the first and second vote percentages, and note what changed.

Further reading

  • Michaelsen, L. K., Knight, A. B., & Fink, L. D. (Eds.). (2004). Team-based learning. Stylus.
  • Mazur, E. (1997). Peer instruction: A user's manual. Prentice Hall.
  • Crouch, C. H., & Mazur, E. (2001). Peer instruction: Ten years of experience and results. American Journal of Physics, 69(9), 970-977.
  • Johnson, D. W., Johnson, R. T., & Smith, K. A. (1998). Cooperative learning returns to college. Change, 30(4), 26-35.

Citations were compiled for a working draft. Please verify volume, page and edition details before wider circulation.