Toolkit / Chapter 2

Chapter 2 of 6

Problem-Based Learning

Students meet a messy problem first, then work out for themselves what they need to learn.

Best forSelf-directed learning and integrating ideas across subjects
Group sizeTutor groups of 8 to 10, or one tutor with several groups of 5
PreparationHigh. Problem design and tutor guides take time
Session lengthTwo sessions of about 60 minutes, with 3 to 5 days of self-study between

1 What it is

In problem-based learning, the problem comes before the teaching. Students meet an ill-structured scenario, identify what they already know, decide what they need to find out, study independently and then return to apply what they learned. The tutor facilitates the process rather than delivering content.

It differs from case-based learning in where it starts: after some teaching versus before any teaching; who sets the objectives (teacher versus students); and how complete the information is (mostly complete versus deliberately incomplete).

Defining features

  • Ill-structured problem with gaps students must find
  • Students set their own learning issues
  • Independent study between two sessions
  • Tutor asks questions rather than explains

What it is not

  • A lecture followed by a problem, which is a case
  • A project, which takes longer and builds a product
  • Leaving students alone without guidance

How a session runs

  1. Clarify termsUnfamiliar words first
  2. Define the problemWhat needs explaining?
  3. BrainstormWhat does the group already know or suspect?
  4. OrganiseGroup ideas into explanations or hypotheses
  5. Agree learning issuesWhat must we find out?
  6. Study independentlyBooks, journals and databases
  7. Return and applyShare findings and apply them to the problem

2 Background

Origins

Howard Barrows developed PBL at McMaster University medical school in the late 1960s. Maastricht University and many health-science schools later refined it. Barrows and Tamblyn (1980) remains the foundational text.

Learning theory

Constructivism: learners build new understanding on prior knowledge, and recalling it primes them for new material. It also builds self-directed learning, where students learn to identify gaps and fill them, a habit professionals need for life.

Evidence, including the critique

A meta-analysis by Dochy and colleagues (2003) found slightly lower knowledge scores but significantly better skills application and longer retention. Kirschner, Sweller and Clark (2006) argued novices learn poorly with minimal guidance. The reply (Hmelo-Silver, Duncan and Chinn, 2007) was that good PBL is heavily scaffolded. It works when students are supported.

The Indian context

Large cohorts, fixed timetables and examination pressure make pure PBL hard. Three adaptations help: hybrid PBL across a week, 20-minute mini-problems inside a lecture, and tutor pools of senior students and research scholars after short training. NPTEL, SWAYAM and PubMed supply self-study material.

3 Implementation across courses

Pick a subject to see a worked example. Adapt the topic to your own syllabus unit.

Organophosphate poisoning

A farmer is admitted with excessive salivation, pinpoint pupils and muscle twitching. Students list what they do not understand, then study cholinesterase inhibition, atropine, pralidoxime and decontamination.

Students produce: Concept map, management algorithm and a five-minute group presentation

Paediatric liquid for a bitter drug

A hospital needs an oral liquid for a poorly soluble, bitter drug not available commercially. Students identify solubility, taste masking, preservation and stability issues.

Students produce: Preformulation plan, prototype formula and stability protocol

Herbal product fails its label claim

A market surveillance report shows a herbal product below its claim. Students decide how to confirm it, which method to use, how to validate it and whether adulteration is likely.

Students produce: Analytical strategy report referencing ICH validation parameters

Non-prescription antibiotic sales

Antibiotic dispensing without a prescription is rising in a town. Students study resistance, Schedule H and H1 rules, stewardship and counselling.

Students produce: Community intervention proposal with measurable indicators

Common pitfalls and how to avoid them

The problem is too well structuredRemove information. If students can solve it from the page, it is a case, not a problem
Groups chase irrelevant rabbit holesGive tutors a guide listing expected learning issues so they can steer with questions
Some students do not contributeAdd peer assessment and a short individual quiz after the second session
Students feel lost without lecturesOffer a short resource session after learning issues are set
Assessment still rewards recall onlyInclude a problem-based written or oral assessment so method and exam point the same way

4 Enriching your practice

This part is for you to work through on your own. Your ticks are saved in this browser only.

Reflection prompts

  • What does my cohort do when a question has no clear answer?
  • Which topic spans several subjects and could become one problem?
  • How comfortable am I saying I do not know, let us find out?
  • What resources can my students realistically reach in three days?

Readiness checklist

Try it this week

Turn one lecture topic into a 20-minute mini-problem. Present the scenario first, ask groups to list what they would need to know, and only then teach the gaps they named.

Further reading

  • Barrows, H. S., & Tamblyn, R. M. (1980). Problem-based learning: An approach to medical education. Springer.
  • Dochy, F., et al. (2003). Effects of problem-based learning: A meta-analysis. Learning and Instruction, 13(5), 533-568.
  • Hmelo-Silver, C. E. (2004). Problem-based learning: What and how do students learn? Educational Psychology Review, 16(3), 235-266.
  • Kirschner, P. A., Sweller, J., & Clark, R. E. (2006). Why minimal guidance during instruction does not work. Educational Psychologist, 41(2), 75-86.
  • Hmelo-Silver, C. E., Duncan, R. G., & Chinn, C. A. (2007). Scaffolding and achievement in problem-based and inquiry learning. Educational Psychologist, 42(2), 99-107.

Citations were compiled for a working draft. Please verify volume, page and edition details before wider circulation.